KMLM List

["Bodfish,John" <bodfishj@xxxxxxxx>]

Silade:
 
I've just checked one of OCLC's implementations and it sends the "Description", 
e.g. "Electronic mail address". Looking at it now I wish we'd used the text 
from the "URI scheme" column, but I think we followed the examples given in the 
Data Dictionary under "Electronic Address / Electronic Address Type", which 
are: "electronic mail address, IP address, telephone number". Unfortunately 
none of those appear exactly as that in the IANA registry today (nor did they 
appear so in the IANA registry at the time we wrote NCIP version 1, see 
http://web.archive.org/web/20020815000000-20050101235959/http://www.iana.org/assignments/uri-schemes).
 For instance, the IANA registry has "telephone" not "telephone number".
 
Given that the standard overlooks this detail I think we should ask the entire 
implementation group whether the preferred choice is the "Description" or the 
"URI Scheme". I'll start asking around here (OCLC).
 
John

________________________________

From: ncipinfo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:ncipinfo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of ;
Robert Walsh
Sent: Friday, July 09, 2010 7:45 AM
To: 刘小丰
Cc: ncipinfo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Re: [ncipinfo] Electronic Address Type


Hi Silade,

That I do not know.  Perhaps someone else on this list can provide some 
guidance.

Sorry...

Rob Walsh 
EnvisionWare, Inc.
NCIP Maintenance Agency

Sent from my iPhone

On Jul 8, 2010, at 9:08 PM, 刘小丰  <lxf615@xxxxxxxx> wrote:



Hi Mr. Robert,
Yes,I know this.I meas which value  I should use in NCIP element.There are two 
fileds in the  IANA, URI Scheme,and Description.should I use the URI Scheme or 
Description as the value of NCIP element?In the examples for Electronic Address 
Type,IP address and telephone number are not in the IANA.

--- 10年7月9日，周五, Robert Walsh <rwalsh@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> 写道：


        
        发件人: Robert Walsh <rwalsh@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
        主题: Re: [ncipinfo] Electronic Address Type
        收件人: "刘小丰" <lxf615@xxxxxxxx>
        抄送: <mailto:ncipinfo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> ncipinfo@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        日期: 2010年7月9日,周五,上午2:13
        
        
        Hi Silade, 

        You should be using a value from the IANA scheme in the NCIP message 
element.  You may include that IANA URI as the scheme using the optional 
"scheme" attribute.  In Version 1, it was required to specify both the scheme 
and the value, but in Version 2, the scheme/value pair elements were changed to 
strings with an option to include the scheme as an attribute.

        Rob Walsh
        EnvisionWare, Inc.
        NCIP Maintenance Agency


        On Jul 7, 2010, at 11:14 PM, 刘小丰 wrote:


Hello
I see the IANA URI Scheme.http://www.iana.org/assignments/uri-schemes.html.But ;
I have a problem.I should send the URI Scheme or description defined in IANA 
URI Scheme in a NCIP message

Silade
Insignia