Comment Details - National Information Standards Organization

Comment #00240 - Role of DataCite - RP-15-201x Suppl_TWG_draft_for_comments_final-rev.pdf (revision #1)

<< Previous Comment in Document Document Details | Add Comment

Comment 240

Addressed (Unresolved)

NISO RP-15-201x, Recommended Practices for Online Supplemental Journal Article Materials, Part B:... (Revision 1)

Comment Submitted by Irina Sens 2012-09-19 05:03:14	The description of the role of DataCite is very weak: In some cases, datasets associated with an article may have been registered via DataCite, a registration agency focused on research data. If that is the case, the publisher should not re-register the dataset through CrossRef, but simply link to the DOI already assigned to the dataset. There is a joint statement between STM Assocation and DataCite (and Crossref signed it as well): http://datacite.org/node/65 In the self-image of DataCite it says: Assigning persistent identifiers to datasets By working with data centres to assign persistent identifiers to datasets, we are developing an infrastructure that supports simple and effective methods of data citation, discovery, and access. Citable datasets become legitimate contributions to scholarly communication, paving the way for new metrics and publication models that recognise and reward data sharing. Supporting File: 2012_06_14_STM_DataCite_Joint_Statement.pdf

Comment Submitted by
Irina Sens
2012-09-19 05:03:14

The description of the role of DataCite is very weak: In some cases, datasets associated with an article may have been registered via DataCite, a registration agency focused on research data. If that is the case, the publisher should not re-register the dataset through CrossRef, but simply link to the DOI already assigned to the dataset. There is a joint statement between STM Assocation and DataCite (and Crossref signed it as well): http://datacite.org/node/65
In the self-image of DataCite it says: Assigning persistent identifiers to datasets

By working with data centres to assign persistent identifiers to datasets, we are developing an infrastructure that supports simple and effective methods of data citation, discovery, and access. Citable datasets become legitimate contributions to scholarly communication, paving the way for new metrics and publication models that recognise and reward data sharing.

Supporting File:

2012_06_14_STM_DataCite_Joint_Statement.pdf

Submitter Proposed Solution	DataCite is a non-commercial registration agency for datasets and datasets should be register by DataCite. DataCite and CrossRef make the linking between articles and reserach data possible.

Submitter Proposed Solution

DataCite is a non-commercial registration agency for datasets and datasets should be register by DataCite. DataCite and CrossRef make the linking between articles and reserach data possible.

Developer Response	Your comment was carefully considered by the Technical Working Group in their review and subsequent revision of the Recommended Practice before publication, which occurred late last week after approvals from both NISO and NFAIS leadership. Responses to comments can be found at http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/document.php?document_id=9757 The published Recommended Practice can be found at http://www.niso.org/publications/rp/rp-15-2013 thank you for your support of NISO and NFAIS. Nettie Lagace, NISO Associate Director for Programs

Developer Response

Your comment was carefully considered by the Technical Working Group in their review and subsequent revision of the Recommended Practice before publication, which occurred late last week after approvals from both NISO and NFAIS leadership. Responses to comments can be found at http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/document.php?document_id=9757 The published Recommended Practice can be found at http://www.niso.org/publications/rp/rp-15-2013 thank you for your support of NISO and NFAIS. Nettie Lagace, NISO Associate Director for Programs

Title	NISO RP-15-201x, Recommended Practices for Online Supplemental Journal Article Materials, Part B: Technical Recommendations
File Name	RP-15-201x Suppl_TWG_draft_for_comments_final-rev.pdf	State	Draft
Date Added	2012-08-06 11:10:25	Revision Number	1
Submitter Name	Cynthia Hodgson	Size	256K

Summary	Role of DataCite	State (Disposition)	Addressed (Unresolved)
Date Added	2012-09-19 05:03:14	Last Updated	2013-02-01 08:47:16
Submitter Name	Irina Sens	Assigned To	Irina Sens
Company Name	DataCite e. V.	Response	Fixed
Interest Category		Category	Substantive
Origin	Public Review	Section, Page, Line	Section 3.1, Page 8
Item	Paragraph	Item Description	Background

Comment #00240 - Role of DataCite - RP-15-201x Suppl_TWG_draft_for_comments_final-rev.pdf (revision #1)

Document Information

Comment Information