Home | Public Area

#00236 Comment Details - RP-15-201x Suppl_TWG_draft_for_comments_final-rev.pdf (revision #1)

Document Information
Title NISO RP-15-201x, Recommended Practices for Online Supplemental Journal Article Materials, Part B: Technical Recommendations
File Name RP-15-201x Suppl_TWG_draft_for_comments_final-rev.pdf State Draft
Date Added 2012-08-06 11:10:25 Revision Number 1
Submitter Name Cynthia Hodgson Size 256K
Comment Information
Summary
reference to <oXygen/> XML Editor
State (Disposition) New (Unresolved)
Date Added 2012-09-07 19:44:53 Last Updated 2012-09-07 19:44:53
Submitter Name Kevin Hawkins Assigned To Unassigned
Company Name MPublishing, University of Michigan Library Response None
Interest Category Category N/A
Origin Public Review Section, Page, Line Section 2.2, Page 3
Item N/A Item Description
Submitter Comment
You currently use the phrase "oXygen-generated diagrams and content models" without naming the program correctly. It's also syntactically ambiguous since it sounds like the content models were generated by <oXygen/> XML Editor as well, though I'm not sure you meant this.
Submitter Proposed Solution
I suggest rephrasing as "diagrams and content models generated by the <oXygen/> XML Editor". If the content models aren't generated by this program, then the sentence should instead end with "as well as in the form of the Tag Library, diagrams generated by <oXygen/> XML Editor, and content models".