Home | Public Area

Document Details - NISO RP-19-201x, Open Discovery Initiative: Promoting Transparency in Discovery (draft for comments)


Document Details
Share |
Document Number RP-19
Title NISO RP-19-201x, Open Discovery Initiative: Promoting Transparency in Discovery (draft for comments)
Name NISO RP-19-201x, Open Discovery Initiative: Promoting Transparency in Discovery (draft for comments) (311K)
Revision 2
Description Draft for public comments: October 16 - November 18, 2013.

To submit comments, click on the "add a comment" link at the top of the Document Details.
Document State Final (Released for distribution.)
Group / Folder Open Discovery Initiative (ODI) / Ballot Documents
Submitter By Cynthia Hodgson on Tuesday, 15 October 2013 04:40pm
Modified By Cynthia Hodgson on Saturday, 15 March 2014 08:33am
Public URL http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/document.php?document_id=11606&wg_abbrev=odi

Referenced Items

Name Type Date

Draft for Public Comments

Last Updated: 2014-04-29

Issuance of a draft for public comment.

page=ballotrefitems&type=document
Draft for Public Comments Activity (Document) 2014-04-29 No Access

* Estimated completion date


Document Revisions
Name # State Submitter Date Action
2
Final
Cynthia Hodgson
2013-10-15
This doc
NISO RP-19-201x, Open Discovery Initiative: Promoting Transparency in Discovery
1
Draft
Nettie Lagace
2013-10-04
(private)
NISO RP-19-201x, Open Discovery Initiative: Promoting Transparency in Discovery
0
Final
Cynthia Hodgson
2013-09-20
(private)

Comments
Showing 71 of 71 comments
Subject # State Submitter Date Action
Metadata requirements too minimal
2
New
Linda Wobbe
2013-11-18
data elements in the supply chain
2
New
Beth Guay
2013-11-18
Reporting format for metrics to content providers
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
Linking recommendations
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
Linking recommendations
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
Accessibility of the discovery service content listings
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
Data elements for content listings from DPs
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
DP content listing - clarification sought
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
Enhanced metadata
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
Basic vs Enhanced metadata
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
ODI compliance
2
New
Tamar Sadeh
2013-11-18
content providers roles as "actors" vs. "stakeholders"
2
New
Beth Guay
2013-11-18
Format / media type as basic data element
2
New
Anke Hofmann
2013-11-18
IEEE Comments
2
New
Nancy Blair-DeLeon
2013-11-17
Comma needs to be removed
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Bad example for counting results clicks
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Metadata Information Included in Content Listings
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Metadata vs. Indexed Metadata
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Title row is duplicated
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Badly formatted bullets
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Open Repository for Article Metadata
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Rich metadata definition
2
New
Lucy Harrison
2013-11-15
Fair and Unbiased Linking
2
New
Jill Lectka
2013-11-13
Usage Metrics for Libraries
2
New
Jill Lectka
2013-11-13
Distributin of Metadata
2
New
Jill Lectka
2013-11-13
Fair Linking
2
New
Jill Lectka
2013-11-13
Linking and Relevancy Ranking
2
New
Jill Lectka
2013-11-13
Language Element
2
New
Marti Heyman
2013-11-13
APIs
2
New
Andrea Marchitelli
2013-11-12
Examples of publication type in table 6
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
Examples of publication format in table 6
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
“Contributor” in table 3 is confusing
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
Enhanced metadata is not sufficient for audio, video, and musica
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
Content type and format combined in tables 1 and 2.
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
Tables 2, 4: examples for “media” only pertain to images
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
Table 1, wrong content in final row
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
URL for Music Discovery Requiprements
2
New
Nara Newcomer
2013-11-11
for resource type was the RDA/Onix framework considered?
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
discovery service content listings
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
Strange definition of contributor
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
Basic metadata needs expansion
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
define open access
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
metadata definitions
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
APIs in scope
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
benefits for A&I services
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
sources of metadata
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
Specialized interfaces and functionality
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
clarify "and other representations"
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
Use of the term "indexed search"
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-11-05
Usage reporting at customer level
2
New
Alexandra de Lange
2013-11-04
re: Relevance ranking out of scope?
2
New
Alison Hitchens
2013-10-29
3.2.1.2 minimal metadata insufficient
2
New
Melissa Belvadi
2013-10-25
typo in 3.2.1.2 table 1
2
New
Melissa Belvadi
2013-10-25
citation v full text not binary: rich metadata
2
New
Melissa Belvadi
2013-10-25
Promoting transparency in discovery
2
New
Edith Reschke
2013-10-22
Language of the document in Basic Metadata
2
New
Ewa Nieszkowska-Serlan
2013-10-20
Minimum level of metrics
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
The nature of recommendations, best practices, voluntary conform
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Types of indexed items
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Linking: wrong title
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Basic metadata elements
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Single search box
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Libraries as stakeholders
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Licensee/licensor
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Linked Data
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Definition of harvest
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Definition of central index
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
APIs out of scope?
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Relevance ranking out of scope?
2
New
Lukas Koster
2013-10-18
Enhanced Metadata: Subject Terms
2
New
Keith Weimer
2013-10-16
Test Comment
2
New
Cynthia Hodgson
2013-10-15